Skip to content
Sharp Six

News

PFFanalysis

NFL rookie rankings: Highest-graded players after Week 10

PFF's Week 2 rookie grade leaderboard is topped by Cowboys LB Jaishawn Barham at 84.8, with Josiah Trotter, Antonio Williams, Caleb Downs and Blake Miller rounding out the top five.

PFF's 2026 NFL rookie rankings highlight the 15 highest-graded first-year players through Week 10, with a minimum requirement of 200 snaps. Carolina Panthers safety Zakee Wheatley leads the list with an 89.8 PFF overall grade, followed by Cleveland Browns safety Emmanuel McNeil-Warren.
— PFF

Sharp take

Sharp SixNo action

A PFF grade list is a scouting exercise, not a fantasy signal. Williams is a WR buried at 5.4 points last week with a -95.7 value over replacement on a Washington offense projected for 40.5 points as a touchdown-plus underdog. None of that changes because a grading model liked his blocking or route-running. Leave him on waivers where he belongs.

Confidence75%
  • waiver

Our read on PFF’s reporting. Not a fact beyond the source.

Players: Jaylen Warren

Teams: Carolina Panthers, Cleveland Browns

Read at PFF (opens in a new tab)