Skip to content
Sharp Six

The Record

Every call we published, graded against what the players actually scored. The misses come first.

Updated under an hour ago

1692–524

76% right

3010 made no claim (Hold, No action). 596 never took the field. 5822 calls counted in all.

Week 11 is still being played. Week 11 grades land when the results are in.

The record, week by week

The take calls in the headline and every start/sit call further down, together, on the headline’s rule: a right or a wrong moves the line, a call that claimed nothing or a player who did not play does not.

Week 2 · 814–124 · season 814–124Week 3 · 941–186 · season 1755–310Week 4 · 732–187 · season 2487–497Week 5 · 568–130 · season 3055–627Week 6 · 481–92 · season 3536–719Week 7 · 664–126 · season 4200–845Week 8 · 579–145 · season 4779–990Week 9 · 590–138 · season 5369–1128Week 10 · 485–98 · season 5854–1226
Net wins, rights minus wrongs, week by week from zero. Pushes do not move the line.
Takes and start/sit, by week
WeekRecordRunning recordNet wins
Week 2814–124–0814–124–0+690
Week 3941–186–01755–310–0+1445
Week 4732–187–02487–497–0+1990
Week 5568–130–03055–627–0+2428
Week 6481–92–03536–719–0+2817
Week 7664–126–04200–845–0+3355
Week 8579–145–04779–990–0+3789
Week 9590–138–05369–1128–0+4241
Week 10485–98–05854–1226–0+4628

Start here

What we got wrong

The calls that missed by the most, worst first. The quote is what we published at the time.

  1. Davante AdamsWR · LARWeek 2
    Adams put up 5.6 points and Stafford 6.7, which is not a slump, that's just what an aging passing game looks like now.

    We said Bench. He scored 39.5 against a line of 9.0.

    Fantasy football start or sit Week 2: Davante Adams, Matthew Stafford, Colby Parkinson - The Big Lead

  2. Tyler AllgeierRB · ARIWeek 8
    Allgeier put up 7.9 and 5.8 the last two weeks and is a 217 sharp rank with a negative VORP, and Mitchell scored zero in Week 7 off a 239 rank.

    We said Fade. He scored 36.1 against a line of 6.0.

    Week 9 Fantasy Football Early Waiver Wire Pickups: Tyler Allgeier, Adonai Mitchell among top adds

  3. Puka NacuaWR · LARWeek 9
    Drop your worst bench piece, grab the best available receiver, and revisit Nacua only when a return timeline actually exists.

    We said Bench. He scored 36.0 against a line of 9.9.

    One more take made the same call that week.

    NFL news, live updates, trade deadline rumors: Vikings trade for QB Kirk Cousins; Colts don't trade Jonathan Taylor, send Josh Downs to Chiefs

  4. Carson WentzQB · MINWeek 3
    Wentz is rostered in zero percent of these leagues and put up 20.5 points the last time he was handed the job.

    We said Add. He scored 0.0 against a line of 22.6 the week after.

    Vikings to start Wentz with Murray on the mend

  5. Lamar JacksonQB · BALWeek 8
    Jackson's matchup at Buffalo with a 54.5 total is the only number here that matters, and it says start him regardless of what this column adds.

    We said Start. He scored 0.0 against a line of 21.4.

    5 more takes made the same call that week.

    Lamar Jackson, A.J. Brown, NFL Injury Statuses and Fantasy Impact for Week 8 - Bleacher Report

  6. Malik WillisQB · MIAWeek 10
    Willis carries a -26.9 value over replacement, which is a long way of saying he was never in your lineup.

    We said Add. He scored 0.0 against a line of 21.0 the week after.

    Dolphins place QB Malik Willis, DT Zach Sieler on injured reserve

Every start/sit call

The start/sit page tiers every rostered player in the field before kickoff, and every one of those rows is graded here. Nobody drew this list up afterwards, which is why it is the number worth arguing with.

4162–70286% right

avoid
2290–4898%
0 no claim · 22043 did not play
bench
1139–15888%
0 no claim · 68 did not play
start
361–35051%
0 no claim · 11 did not play
must start
372–14672%
0 no claim · 2 did not play
flex
0–0no claim
788 no claim · 0 did not play
out
0–0no claim
1202 no claim · 0 did not play

Which way we moved a player

Each take also says whether a player is heading up or down. A weaker claim than the action, and graded the same way.

2199–81373% right

down
1577–54974%
0 no claim · 1131 did not play
up
622–26470%
0 no claim · 52 did not play
neutral
0–0no claim
3701 no claim · 0 did not play

A separate record

Prop picks

116–110–0

51% right

The prop picks, three stars and up, each graded against the line it was frozen with. Pushes are counted and left out of the percentage. 4 void, where the player did not play, counted nowhere. Leans are on the board and in no number here.

Counted since week 3, the first graded week. No backtest stands in for the weeks before it.

By market

Passing yards
11–12–0 48%
23 picks
Rushing yards
32–38–0 46%
70 picks
Receiving yards
28–27–0 51%
58 picks · 3 void
Receptions
44–32–0 58%
77 picks · 1 void
Anytime touchdown
1–1–0 50%
2 picks

The Sharp Model’s player props at three stars and up, frozen with the line and graded against what the player actually did. The board and the rules are on the props page.

The misses

  1. Emmett JohnsonKCRushing yards: Under 73.5Wrong · 101 yards★★★★☆Week 10
  2. Ja'Marr ChaseCINReceptions: Under 7.5Wrong · 11 catches★★★★☆Week 10
  3. A.J. BrownNEReceiving yards: Over 51.5Wrong · 27 yards★★★☆☆Week 10
  4. Alvin KamaraNOReceptions: Under 2.5Wrong · 3 catches★★★☆☆Week 10
  5. Bhayshul TutenJAXRushing yards: Under 68.5Wrong · 88 yards★★★☆☆Week 10
  6. Christian McCaffreySFRushing yards: Over 62.5Wrong · 62 yards★★★☆☆Week 10

The hits

  1. Brock PurdySFPassing yards: Over 261.5Right · 389 yards★★★☆☆Week 10
  2. Christian WatsonGBReceptions: Under 4.5Right · 3 catches★★★☆☆Week 10
  3. Drake LondonATLReceiving yards: Over 72.5Right · 109 yards★★★☆☆Week 10
  4. Drew LockSEAPassing yards: Over 203.5Right · 240 yards★★★☆☆Week 10
  5. Elic AyomanorTENReceiving yards: Over 26.5Right · 79 yards★★★☆☆Week 10
  6. J.J. McCarthyNYGPassing yards: Over 201.5Right · 293 yards★★★☆☆Week 10

The rule

Every call is graded against the start-worthy line: the FFPC points the last startable player at that position actually scored that week, in a 12-team lineup — the same replacement level the draft board, the waiver board and the tier column all run on. Start, Add, must start, start and an up arrow are right when the player beat the line; Bench, Fade, bench, avoid and a down arrow are right when he did not. An Add is graded on the week after the news, because that is when a roster move pays. Hold, No action, flex, out and a neutral arrow claim nothing, so they are counted above and never graded. A player who did not take the field has no result and stays out of the win-loss entirely. The margin is his points minus the line, which is the order the two lists above are in. Prop picks keep a rule of their own: right, wrong or a push against the book’s line they were frozen with, on the side they took, and void when the player did not play, which counts nowhere.