Skip to content
Sharp Six

Against the spread

Week 11 · 13 games · 0 picks · 13 leans

Updated 9 h ago
The wire

Week 11 at a glance

13 games, 0 plays; biggest lean IND 6.3 points.

One spoke per game in kickoff order, clockwise from the top. The farther out the dot, the harder the Sharp Model leans; each ring is a point. Red dots are the Sharp picks, grey the leans. Every dot opens its game.

  1. IND +12.5, 2 of 5 stars, lean 6.3 points, a lean
  2. ARI +16.5, 2 of 5 stars, lean 5.8 points, a lean
  3. CAR −2.5, 2 of 5 stars, lean 2.2 points, a lean
  4. JAX −6, 2 of 5 stars, lean 2.8 points, a lean
  5. BUF −16.5, 1 of 5 stars, lean 0.6 points, a lean
  6. NO +11.5, 2 of 5 stars, lean 3.1 points, a lean
  7. TB +6.5, 2 of 5 stars, lean 3.4 points, a lean
  8. DAL −8.5, 1 of 5 stars, lean 0.0 points, a lean
  9. LAC −3.5, 2 of 5 stars, lean 3.1 points, a lean
  10. LV +10, 2 of 5 stars, lean 1.5 points, a lean
  11. PIT −4.5, 1 of 5 stars, lean 0.1 points, a lean
  12. SF −3, 2 of 5 stars, lean 4.6 points, a lean
  13. WAS +6.5, 2 of 5 stars, lean 2.1 points, a lean

Week 11

Zero picks this week, which means your spreadsheet gets a night off. Thirteen games on the board and nothing clears three stars, just a stack of 2-star leans -- Jacksonville laying 6 on the road at New York, San Francisco at -3 over Minnesota, that kind of thing worth watching and nothing more. None of that is a pick, so don't treat it like one. The record sits at 7-2-0 on live picks, which is the only number here that counts. Nothing graded this week. Check back when the board gives us something to grade.

From the Sharp Model, off the week’s picks and the record so far.

The record

7–2–0

78% right

The Sharp picks, three stars and up, every live one graded against the line it was made on. Pushes are counted and left out of the percentage. Nothing below three stars is in this number.

Week 11 is still being played. Its grades land when the scores do.

Week 3 · 3–0 · season 3–0Week 5 · 3–0 · season 6–0Week 7 · 0–1 · season 6–1Week 8 · 1–1 · season 7–2
Net wins, rights minus wrongs, week by week from zero. Pushes do not move the line.
Sharp spread picks, by week
WeekRecordRunning recordNet wins
Week 33–0–03–0–0+3
Week 53–0–06–0–0+6
Week 70–1–06–1–0+5
Week 81–1–07–2–0+5

By stars

★★★★★
2–0–0 100%
2 picks
★★★★☆
0–0–0 nothing decided
0 picks
★★★☆☆
5–2–0 71%
7 picks

One and two stars are leans. Shown in the table, counted nowhere. 122 leans this season.

By signal

Ratings
54–61–3 47%
fired 131
Our spread against the market line: the market’s own numbers, fitted on the season’s posted lines, plus what results add, capped at 2 points.
Rest
18–12–1 60%
fired 37
A gap of 3 days or more between the two teams’ rest. 1.5 points to the rested side.
Public
18–15–2 55%
fired 35
65% or more of the spread money on one side. 1 point the other way.
Weather
0–0–0 nothing decided
not fired yet
Outdoors with wind at 20 mph or a 60% chance of rain. 1 point to the underdog.
Quarterback
12–13–0 48%
fired 31
The starting quarterback out, doubtful, on injured reserve, PUP or suspended. 4 points against his team. Live weeks only.

Each signal is graded on the side it favoured, whichever side the pick took, over every game it fired on, leans included.

Backtest

Weeks 1 and 2 had too few lines for the system to hold an opinion; every game was a lean. Run after the fact against the closing line; the signal records above still grade every game. A demonstration of the system, not a record.

Closing line value

Beat the close in 2 of 9 live picks (22%), average −0.1 points.

2 beat the close · 5 closed where we took them · 2 gave points up

The closing line is the sharpest number there is: the market’s last word before kickoff, with every opinion in it. A pick that beats it took a number the market then moved toward, whatever the score did afterwards. A process that beats it consistently is a process, whatever one week’s scores say; one that does not is getting its wins from somewhere else.

Live Sharp picks only. A backtest was made against the close and has nothing to beat; a lean is not a pick. The close is the median spread across books from the last pull before kickoff.

Week 11: the Sharp picks

A pick is a game where the market’s own numbers disagree with the line by 3 points or more, a signal fired on that side, and the number we land on is on that side too; that puts it at three stars and up. Each one carries the case it was published with; the case does not change after kickoff and neither does the line under it.

No game this week cleared the gate, so there are no picks. The table below still has a side on every game, as leans.

The Six this week

The leaderboard

Each Sharp’s picks for week 11, up to five, starred one to three, saved before kickoff and frozen with the line. A chip marked agrees is on the same side as the Sharp Model. Every Sharp also fills a full card; both records are kept.

RankSharpSharp PicksHitGraded
1Curtis7–3–170%11
9 of 10The Sharp Model7–2–078%9
5 of 10hotrod0three2–3–040%5

Ranked by Sharp-picks hit rate once a row has 10 graded Sharp Picks. Under that it is listed after the ranked rows with its count, because a short run is not a place on a table. The Sharp Model is held to the same rule.

Week 11: every game

One row per game, one side each. The rows at one and two stars are leans, marked no play: shown so the system’s every call is on the page, counted in no record. The line is the one the side was taken against; the current line appears beside it only when the market has moved.

GameSideOursEdgeStarsResult
IND at HOU
Thu 8:15 PM
IND +12.5IND +6.2+6.3
★★☆☆☆no play
–
ARI at KC
Sun 1:00 PM
ARI +16.5ARI +10.7+5.8
★★☆☆☆no play
–
BAL at CAR
Sun 1:00 PM
CAR −2.5CAR −0.7−1.8
★★☆☆☆no play
–
JAX at NYG
Sun 1:00 PM
JAX −6JAX −6.3+0.3
★★☆☆☆no play
–
MIA at BUF
Sun 1:00 PM
BUF −16.5BUF −13.1−3.4
★☆☆☆☆no play
–
NO at CHI
Sun 1:00 PM
NO +11.5NO +6.9+4.6
★★☆☆☆no play
–
TB at DET
Sun 1:00 PM
TB +6.5TB +4.6+1.9
★★☆☆☆no play
–
TEN at DAL
Sun 1:00 PM
DAL −8.5DAL −8.50.0
★☆☆☆☆no play
–
NYJ at LAC
Sun 4:05 PM
LAC −3.5LAC −2.6−0.9
★★☆☆☆no play
–
LV at DEN
Sun 4:25 PM
LV +10LV +7+3.0
★★☆☆☆no play
–
PIT at PHI
Sun 4:25 PM
PIT −4.5PIT −2.1−2.4
★☆☆☆☆no play
–
MIN at SF
Sun 8:20 PM
SF −3SF −3.6+0.6
★★☆☆☆no play
–
CIN at WAS
Mon 8:15 PM
WAS +6.5WAS +5.9+0.6
★★☆☆☆no play
–

Close and CLV land with the grade. A lean carries them for the reader and counts in neither block above.

Past weeks

Week 100–0–014 games · 0 picks · 14 leans · all graded

Zero picks at three stars or better this week, out of fourteen games on the board. That's not a slump, that's the market refusing to hand us anything clean, and the record stands at 7-2-0 for actually pulling the trigger when it's there. There are fourteen leans sitting at one or two stars, things like TEN +10.5 against Jacksonville and DAL -4.5 at home on San Francisco, but a lean is a lean because it isn't good enough to be a pick. Read them if you want texture for your own guesses. Don't mistake any of them for what the record is actually built on.

From the Sharp Model, off the week’s picks and the record so far.

GameSideOursEdgeStarsResult
WAS at NYG
Thu 8:15 PM
WAS +2.5WAS +1.9+0.6
★★☆☆☆no play
Right · +5.5WAS 24 at NYG 21
NE at DET
Sun 9:30 AM
NE +2.5NE +2.3+0.2
★☆☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −22.5NE 10 at DET 35
BUF at NYJ
Sun 1:00 PM
NYJ +8.5NYJ +7.4+1.1
★☆☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −10.5BUF 31 at NYJ 12
CAR at NO
Sun 1:00 PM
CAR +1.5CAR −0.1+1.6
★★☆☆☆no play
Right · +4.5CAR 20 at NO 17
HOU at CLE
Sun 1:00 PM
HOU −4.5HOU −4.9+0.4
★★☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −7.5HOU 24 at CLE 27
JAX at TEN
Sun 1:00 PM
TEN +10.5TEN +9.8+0.7
★★☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −6.5JAX 40 at TEN 23
KC at ATL
Sun 1:00 PM
KC −3.5KC −3.8+0.3
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +18.5KC 35 at ATL 13
MIA at IND
Sun 1:00 PM
IND −2.5IND −5+2.5
★★☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −0.5MIA 22 at IND 24
MIN at GB
Sun 1:00 PM
GB −4.5GB −1−3.5
★☆☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −24.5MIN 30 at GB 10
LAR at ARI
Sun 4:05 PM
ARI +9.5ARI +6.5+3.0
★★☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −18.5LAR 34 at ARI 6
SEA at LV
Sun 4:05 PM
LV +3.5LV +5.1−1.6
★★☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −4.5SEA 21 at LV 13
SF at DAL
Sun 4:25 PM
DAL +4.5DAL +1.7+2.8
★★☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −1.5SF 46 at DAL 40
PIT at CIN
Sun 8:20 PM
PIT +3.5PIT +4.6−1.1
★☆☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −16.5PIT 18 at CIN 38
LAC at BAL
Mon 8:15 PM
LAC +5.5LAC +4.4+1.1
★★☆☆☆no play
Right · +8.5LAC 23 at BAL 20
Week 90–0–015 games · 0 picks · 15 leans · all graded

Zero picks at three stars this week, which means zero picks, full stop. The board had 15 games and none of them cleared the bar, so your eyeballs rest easy. There are 15 leans sitting underneath at one or two stars, and MIN +3.5 against Buffalo is the only one worth a glance, but a lean is not a pick and it doesn't go in the ledger. The record stands at 7-2-0 on live picks, untouched this week because nothing touched it. Read the board, note the leans if you like, and don't confuse the two.

From the Sharp Model, off the week’s picks and the record so far.

GameSideOursEdgeStarsResult
JAX at BAL
Thu 8:15 PM
BAL +9.5BAL +1.9+7.6
★★☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −13.5JAX 33 at BAL 10
CIN at ATL
Sun 9:30 AM
CIN −3CIN −3.6+0.6
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +14.0CIN 34 at ATL 17
CLE at NO
Sun 1:00 PM
NO −2.5NO −2.50.0
★★☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −1.5CLE 22 at NO 23
DAL at IND
Sun 1:00 PM
IND +6IND +1.8+4.2
★★☆☆☆no play
Right · +2.0DAL 27 at IND 23
DEN at CAR
Sun 1:00 PM
CAR +2.5CAR +1.9+0.6
★★☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −2.5DEN 26 at CAR 21
DET at MIA
Sun 1:00 PM
DET −7DET −7.1+0.1
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +3.0DET 19 at MIA 9
LAR at WAS
Sun 1:00 PM
WAS +5.5WAS +4.7+0.8
★☆☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −1.5LAR 20 at WAS 13
NYG at PHI
Sun 1:00 PM
PHI +3.5PHI −3.1+6.6
★★☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −4.5NYG 19 at PHI 11
NYJ at KC
Sun 1:00 PM
NYJ +9.5NYJ +8+1.5
★★☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −13.5NYJ 12 at KC 35
HOU at LAC
Sun 4:05 PM
LAC +4.5LAC +2.5+2.0
★☆☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −17.5HOU 44 at LAC 22
ARI at SEA
Sun 4:25 PM
ARI +10.5ARI +9.5+1.0
★☆☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −3.5ARI 3 at SEA 17
GB at NE
Sun 4:25 PM
GB +2.5GB +2.7−0.2
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +20.5GB 45 at NE 27
LV at SF
Sun 4:25 PM
LV +10LV +7.4+2.6
★☆☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −11.0LV 17 at SF 38
TB at CHI
Sun 8:20 PM
TB +6TB +4.3+1.7
★★☆☆☆no play
Right · +3.0TB 24 at CHI 27
BUF at MIN
Mon 8:15 PM
MIN +3.5MIN +0.9+2.6
★★☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −13.5BUF 23 at MIN 6
Week 81–1–014 games · 2 picks · 12 leans · all graded

Week 8: 2 picks at 3 stars or more, and 12 more games we lean on without a pick. The strongest is PIT -3.5 at 3 stars, where the market's own numbers make this line 3 points too kind to CLE. The record over live picks so far is 6-1-0.

Sharp Model lead, numbers only.

CLE at PIT

Sun, Nov 1, 1:00 PM ETGame page★★★☆☆

PIT −3.5

Right · +17.5

Closed PIT −3.5 · closed where we took it

Market PIT −3.5 over CLE. The market’s own numbers make this line 3.0 points too kind to CLE. Results add 0.8 toward CLE. Our number PIT −5.7, an edge of +2.2 before the signals.

  • Ratings · PIT +2.2· right
  • Public · PIT +1.0· right
  • The market's own numbers make this line 3 points too kind to CLE; results move the number 0.8 toward CLE, from PIT giving 6.5 to CLE to PIT giving 5.7 to CLE.
  • 68% of the spread money is on CLE. That is a point to PIT.

The line is PIT giving 3.5 to CLE and our number is PIT giving 5.7 to CLE. The market's own numbers make this line 3 points too kind to CLE; results move the number 0.8 toward CLE, from PIT giving 6.5 to CLE to PIT giving 5.7 to CLE. 68% of the spread money is on CLE. That is a point to PIT. The side is PIT.

Sharp Model case, numbers only. The written case did not land when this pick published.

Final: CLE 6 at PIT 27

Line history7 pulls

PIT: opened −4.25 · taken at −3.5 · closed −3.5

Closed where we took it

The median spread across the books at each pull we hold, on our side. The first pull is where our history starts, not the book’s own opener.

PHI at WAS

Sun, Nov 1, 8:20 PM ETGame page★★★☆☆

PHI +4.5

Wrong · −12.5

Closed PHI +6 · gave up 1.5 to the close

Market WAS −4.5 over PHI. The market’s own numbers make this line 6.6 points too kind to WAS. Results add 1.5 toward WAS. Our number PHI −0.6, an edge of +5.1 before the signals. Line now PHI +6.

  • Ratings · PHI +5.1· wrong
  • Rest · WAS +1.5· right
  • Public · PHI +1.0· wrong
  • Quarterback · WAS +4.0· right
  • The market's own numbers make this line 6.6 points too kind to WAS; results move the number 1.5 toward WAS, from PHI giving 2.1 to WAS to PHI giving 0.6 to WAS.
  • WAS come in on 13 days' rest to PHI's 6.
  • 69% of the spread money is on WAS. That is a point to PHI.
  • PHI's top quarterback, Jalen Hurts, is listed IR.

WAS giving 4.5 to PHI, and our number has PHI giving 0.6 to WAS, which makes this line 6.6 points too kind to WAS. The gap moved the number 1.5 points toward WAS already, from PHI giving 2.1 down to 0.6, and the public is still leaning 69% on WAS, handing PHI another point nobody priced in. Rest and the quarterback signal both argue for WAS, worth 1.5 and 4 points respectively, but the gap and the fade still clear that by over a point. Take PHI at 3 stars, and don't let a 2-5 record talk you out of a number this lopsided.

From the Sharp Model, off the numbers on this card and nothing else.

Final: PHI 10 at WAS 27

Line history8 pulls

PHI: opened +4 · taken at +4.5 · closed +6

Lost 1.5 to the close

The median spread across the books at each pull we hold, on our side. The first pull is where our history starts, not the book’s own opener.

GameSideOursEdgeStarsResult
CAR at GB
Thu 8:15 PM
CAR +3.5CAR +2.6+0.9
★★☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −4.5CAR 19 at GB 27
ARI at DAL
Sun 1:00 PM
DAL −6DAL −7.6+1.6
★★☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −9.0ARI 33 at DAL 30
ATL at TB
Sun 1:00 PM
ATL +2.5ATL +1.3+1.2
★☆☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −13.5ATL 0 at TB 16
BAL at BUF
Sun 1:00 PM
BUF −3.5BUF −4.4+0.9
★★☆☆☆no play
Right · +22.5BAL 10 at BUF 36
CLE at PIT
Sun 1:00 PM
PIT −3.5PIT −5.7+2.2
★★★☆☆
Right · +17.5CLE 6 at PIT 27
IND at JAX
Sun 1:00 PM
JAX −7.5JAX −6.4−1.1
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +27.5IND 7 at JAX 42
LV at NYJ
Sun 1:00 PM
NYJ +1.5NYJ −0.6+2.1
★★☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −3.5LV 38 at NYJ 33
MIN at DET
Sun 1:00 PM
MIN +3MIN +1.1+1.9
★★☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −1.0MIN 15 at DET 19
TEN at CIN
Sun 1:00 PM
CIN −10CIN −11+1.0
★☆☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −3.0TEN 36 at CIN 43
LAC at LAR
Sun 4:05 PM
LAC +6.5LAC +6.50.0
★★☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −8.5LAC 9 at LAR 24
KC at DEN
Sun 4:25 PM
DEN +1.5DEN +0.2+1.3
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +5.5KC 24 at DEN 28
NE at MIA
Sun 4:25 PM
NE −7.5NE −6.9−0.6
★☆☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −2.5NE 24 at MIA 19
PHI at WAS
Sun 8:20 PM
PHI +4.5PHI −0.6+5.1
★★★☆☆
Wrong · −12.5PHI 10 at WAS 27
CHI at SEA
Mon 8:15 PM
CHI +3.5CHI +3.50.0
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +20.5CHI 34 at SEA 17
Week 70–1–014 games · 1 pick · 13 leans · all graded

One pick this week, and it's a split decision with itself. PHI +4.5 looks 5.3 points too generous to DAL by the market's own numbers, and the public is leaning the wrong way at 80% on Dallas, both pointing to Philadelphia. But Jalen Hurts is listed IR, which is worth four points the other direction, so this lands at 3 stars instead of 5. Take PHI, don't pretend it's clean. The other thirteen games are leans, which means they're opinions, not picks, and they don't touch the record. That record stands at 6-0-0, which is either skill or a short sample pretending to be skill.

From the Sharp Model, off the week’s picks and the record so far.

DAL at PHI

Mon, Oct 26, 8:15 PM ETGame page★★★☆☆

PHI +4.5

Wrong · −12.5

Closed PHI +4.5 · closed where we took it

Market DAL −4.5 over PHI. The market’s own numbers make this line 5.3 points too kind to DAL. Results add 0.2 toward DAL. Our number PHI −0.6, an edge of +5.1 before the signals.

  • Ratings · PHI +5.1· wrong
  • Public · PHI +1.0· wrong
  • Quarterback · DAL +4.0· right
  • The market's own numbers make this line 5.3 points too kind to DAL; results move the number 0.2 toward DAL, from PHI giving 0.8 to DAL to PHI giving 0.6 to DAL.
  • 80% of the spread money is on DAL. That is a point to PHI.
  • PHI's top quarterback, Jalen Hurts, is listed IR.

DAL is giving 4.5 to PHI, and the desk is on PHI anyway. The market's own numbers make this line 5.3 points too kind to DAL, the form has moved 0.2 toward DAL and still leaves our number at PHI giving 0.6, and 80% of the spread money sitting on DAL is worth a point the other way. The quarterback signal cuts hard against this, with Hurts listed IR for PHI, which is exactly why this sits at 3 stars and not higher. PHI goes in at 1-5-0 against the spread this season, which tells you how little style points matter here; take the number, not the record.

From the Sharp Model, off the numbers on this card and nothing else.

Final: DAL 38 at PHI 21

Line history6 pulls

PHI: opened −1 · taken at +4.5 · closed +4.5

Closed where we took it

The median spread across the books at each pull we hold, on our side. The first pull is where our history starts, not the book’s own opener.

GameSideOursEdgeStarsResult
NE at CHI
Thu 8:15 PM
NE +3NE +1.1+1.9
★☆☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −3.0NE 24 at CHI 30
PIT at NO
Sun 9:30 AM
NO +3.5NO +1.2+2.3
★★☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −2.5PIT 16 at NO 10
CIN at BAL
Sun 1:00 PM
CIN +3CIN +1.3+1.7
★★☆☆☆no play
Right · +25.0CIN 35 at BAL 13
CLE at TEN
Sun 1:00 PM
TEN +1.5TEN +0.7+0.8
★★☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −1.5CLE 27 at TEN 24
IND at MIN
Sun 1:00 PM
IND +6.5IND +4.3+2.2
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +0.5IND 10 at MIN 16
MIA at NYJ
Sun 1:00 PM
MIA +4.5MIA +5.3−0.8
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +7.5MIA 28 at NYJ 25
NYG at HOU
Sun 1:00 PM
HOU −10HOU −6.6−3.4
★★☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −16.0NYG 27 at HOU 21
SF at ATL
Sun 1:00 PM
ATL +3.5ATL +3.50.0
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +12.5SF 20 at ATL 29
TB at CAR
Sun 1:00 PM
CAR −3.5CAR −3.6+0.1
★★☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −33.5TB 43 at CAR 13
DEN at ARI
Sun 4:05 PM
DEN −4.5DEN −5+0.5
★★☆☆☆no play
Right · +9.5DEN 30 at ARI 16
GB at DET
Sun 4:25 PM
DET −3DET −3.3+0.3
★★☆☆☆no play
PushGB 17 at DET 20
LAR at LV
Sun 4:25 PM
LV +4.5LV +4.3+0.2
★☆☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −9.5LAR 35 at LV 21
KC at SEA
Sun 8:20 PM
SEA −2.5SEA −0.4−2.1
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +14.5KC 3 at SEA 20
DAL at PHI
Mon 8:15 PM
PHI +4.5PHI −0.6+5.1
★★★☆☆
Wrong · −12.5DAL 38 at PHI 21
Week 60–0–014 games · 0 picks · 14 leans · all graded

Zero picks this week, out of 14 games on the board, and that's the whole column. Fourteen leans sit underneath at one and two stars, which means the market and the model are shrugging at each other and neither one is paying you for it. ARI getting 12.5 at the Rams is the closest thing to a shape here, but a two-star lean is a lean, not a pick, and it doesn't get to borrow the record's credibility. That record stands at 6-0-0 on live picks, and it stays there this week because there's nothing to add to it. Read the leans if you're bored. Don't mistake any of them for a call.

From the Sharp Model, off the week’s picks and the record so far.

GameSideOursEdgeStarsResult
SEA at DEN
Thu 8:15 PM
DEN +3DEN −0.2+3.2
★★☆☆☆no play
Right · +6.0SEA 14 at DEN 17
HOU at JAX
Sun 9:30 AM
JAX −3JAX −3.8+0.8
★☆☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −6.0HOU 34 at JAX 31
BAL at CLE
Sun 1:00 PM
CLE +4.5CLE +5.5−1.0
★★☆☆☆no play
Right · +7.5BAL 10 at CLE 13
CAR at PHI
Sun 1:00 PM
CAR +1.5CAR +2.6−1.1
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +12.5CAR 25 at PHI 14
CHI at ATL
Sun 1:00 PM
ATL +3ATL +1.3+1.7
★★☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −5.0CHI 31 at ATL 23
NO at NYG
Sun 1:00 PM
NO −1.5NO +1.5−3.0
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +5.5NO 34 at NYG 27
NYJ at NE
Sun 1:00 PM
NYJ +7.5NYJ +6.7+0.8
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +0.5NYJ 19 at NE 26
PIT at TB
Sun 1:00 PM
TB +2.5TB PK+2.5
★☆☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −4.5PIT 26 at TB 19
TEN at IND
Sun 1:00 PM
TEN +7TEN +6.4+0.6
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +13.0TEN 26 at IND 20
ARI at LAR
Sun 4:05 PM
ARI +12.5ARI +9.2+3.3
★★☆☆☆no play
Right · +14.5ARI 18 at LAR 16
BUF at LV
Sun 4:25 PM
LV +5.5LV +5.4+0.1
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +2.5BUF 33 at LV 30
LAC at KC
Sun 4:25 PM
LAC +8.5LAC +6.8+1.7
★☆☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −7.5LAC 6 at KC 22
DAL at GB
Sun 8:20 PM
DAL +1.5DAL +1.2+0.3
★★☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −8.5DAL 13 at GB 23
WAS at SF
Mon 8:15 PM
SF −7.5SF −9.8+2.3
★★☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −1.5WAS 17 at SF 23
Week 53–0–015 games · 3 picks · 12 leans · all graded

Three picks this week, two of them five stars, and the record stands at 3-0-0 on live picks alone. Take BAL +3 first: the market's own math says this line is 11.5 points too kind to Atlanta, and 71% of the public money sitting on ATL only sweetens the fade. GB +3 is the other five-star, helped along by Chicago trotting out a quarterback room with its top arm listed Out. NE -3.5 is the lesser three-star, a modest 4.2-point gap with 85% of the money on Las Vegas doing some of the lifting. The other twelve games are leans, not picks, so stop asking which one of those you should've had.

From the Sharp Model, off the week’s picks and the record so far.

CHI at GB

Sun, Oct 11, 1:00 PM ETGame page★★★★★

GB +3

Right · +27.0

Closed GB +1.5 · beat the close by 1.5

Market CHI −3 over GB. The market’s own numbers make this line 5.7 points too kind to CHI. Results add 2.0 toward CHI. Our number GB −0.7, an edge of +3.7 before the signals. Line now GB +1.5.

  • Ratings · GB +3.7· right
  • Quarterback · GB +4.0· right
  • The market's own numbers make this line 5.7 points too kind to CHI; results move the number 2 toward CHI, from GB giving 2.7 to CHI to GB giving 0.7 to CHI.
  • CHI's top quarterback, Caleb Williams, is listed Out.

CHI is giving 3 to GB, and the market's own numbers say that's 5.7 points too kind to CHI. Results already moved this two points toward CHI, from GB giving 2.7 to GB giving 0.7, and the quarterback signal pushes further: CHI's top quarterback, Caleb Williams, is listed out, worth 4 points on its own. GB's straight-up record this season is unremarkable and its against-the-spread mark is ugly, but that's noise against a 3.7-point gap this clean. Take GB, and don't let CHI's shinier record talk you out of it.

From the Sharp Model, off the numbers on this card and nothing else.

Final: CHI 7 at GB 31

Line history7 pulls

GB: opened −2 · taken at +3 · closed +1.5

Beat the close by 1.5

The median spread across the books at each pull we hold, on our side. The first pull is where our history starts, not the book’s own opener.

BAL at ATL

Sun, Oct 11, 8:20 PM ETGame page★★★★★

BAL +3

Right · +10.0

Closed BAL +3 · closed where we took it

Market ATL −3 over BAL. The market’s own numbers make this line 11.5 points too kind to ATL. Results add 2.0 toward ATL. Our number BAL −6.5, an edge of +9.5 before the signals. Line now BAL +3.5.

  • Ratings · BAL +9.5· right
  • Public · BAL +1.0· right
  • The market's own numbers make this line 11.5 points too kind to ATL; results move the number 2 toward ATL, from BAL giving 8.5 to ATL to BAL giving 6.5 to ATL.
  • 71% of the spread money is on ATL. That is a point to BAL.

ATL giving 3 on BAL is not a line, it's a typo. Our own numbers say this gap should run BAL giving 6.5 to ATL, which makes the posted line 11.5 points too kind to Atlanta, and the move already shaded 2 points toward ATL confirms the market knows it. Throw in that 71% of the spread money is piling onto ATL anyway, handing BAL a point just for being unpopular, and you get a 9.5-point gap between our number and the board. BAL is 3-1 straight up and this is where the system's five stars mean something: take Baltimore and stop reading the public's math as if it were yours.

From the Sharp Model, off the numbers on this card and nothing else.

Final: BAL 30 at ATL 23

Line history8 pulls

BAL: opened −6.25 · taken at +3 · closed +3

Closed where we took it

The median spread across the books at each pull we hold, on our side. The first pull is where our history starts, not the book’s own opener.

LV at NE

Sun, Oct 11, 1:00 PM ETGame page★★★☆☆

NE −3.5

Right · +24.5

Closed NE −3.5 · closed where we took it

Market NE −3.5 over LV. The market’s own numbers make this line 4.2 points too kind to LV. Results add 2.0 toward LV. Our number NE −5.7, an edge of +2.2 before the signals.

  • Ratings · NE +2.2· right
  • Public · NE +1.0· right
  • The market's own numbers make this line 4.2 points too kind to LV; results move the number 2 toward LV, from NE giving 7.7 to LV to NE giving 5.7 to LV.
  • 85% of the spread money is on LV. That is a point to NE.

The line is NE giving 3.5 to LV and our number is NE giving 5.7 to LV. The market's own numbers make this line 4.2 points too kind to LV; results move the number 2 toward LV, from NE giving 7.7 to LV to NE giving 5.7 to LV. 85% of the spread money is on LV. That is a point to NE. The side is NE.

Sharp Model case, numbers only. The written case did not land when this pick published.

Final: LV 17 at NE 45

Line history7 pulls

NE: opened −3.5 · taken at −3.5 · closed −3.5

Closed where we took it

The median spread across the books at each pull we hold, on our side. The first pull is where our history starts, not the book’s own opener.

GameSideOursEdgeStarsResult
TB at DAL
Thu 8:15 PM
TB +8.5TB +3.2+5.3
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +16.5TB 24 at DAL 16
PHI at JAX
Sun 9:30 AM
PHI +6.5PHI +2.5+4.0
★★☆☆☆no play
Right · +4.5PHI 17 at JAX 19
CHI at GB
Sun 1:00 PM
GB +3GB −0.7+3.7
★★★★★
Right · +27.0CHI 7 at GB 31
CIN at MIA
Sun 1:00 PM
MIA +7MIA +7.6−0.6
★☆☆☆☆no play
PushCIN 31 at MIA 24
CLE at NYJ
Sun 1:00 PM
CLE +2.5CLE +2.8−0.3
★☆☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −2.5CLE 12 at NYJ 17
HOU at TEN
Sun 1:00 PM
TEN +7TEN +5.2+1.8
★★☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −16.0HOU 26 at TEN 3
IND at PIT
Sun 1:00 PM
PIT −2.5PIT −0.7−1.8
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +9.5IND 22 at PIT 34
LV at NE
Sun 1:00 PM
NE −3.5NE −5.7+2.2
★★★☆☆
Right · +24.5LV 17 at NE 45
MIN at NO
Sun 1:00 PM
MIN −1.5MIN −2.5+1.0
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +8.5MIN 23 at NO 13
NYG at WAS
Sun 1:00 PM
NYG +3NYG −0.2+3.2
★★☆☆☆no play
Right · +3.0NYG 27 at WAS 27
DEN at LAC
Sun 4:05 PM
LAC +3.5LAC +1.1+2.4
★★☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −2.5DEN 23 at LAC 17
DET at ARI
Sun 4:25 PM
ARI +4.5ARI +3.2+1.3
★☆☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −19.5DET 45 at ARI 21
SF at SEA
Sun 4:25 PM
SF +3SF +0.4+2.6
★★☆☆☆no play
Right · +6.0SF 32 at SEA 29
BAL at ATL
Sun 8:20 PM
BAL +3BAL −6.5+9.5
★★★★★
Right · +10.0BAL 30 at ATL 23
BUF at LAR
Mon 8:15 PM
BUF +2.5BUF −0.1+2.6
★★☆☆☆no play
Right · +5.5BUF 37 at LAR 34
Week 40–0–016 games · 0 picks · 16 leans · all graded

Week 4: no picks. Nothing clears 3 stars, which is a result too. 16 games we lean on without a pick. The record over live picks so far is 3-0-0.

Sharp Model lead, numbers only.

GameSideOursEdgeStarsResult
PIT at CLE
Thu 8:15 PM
PIT −2.5PIT −2.7+0.2
★☆☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −5.5PIT 24 at CLE 27
IND at WAS
Sun 9:30 AM
IND −3.5IND +0.2−3.7
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +13.5IND 30 at WAS 13
ARI at NYG
Sun 1:00 PM
NYG +1.5NYG −2.8+4.3
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +13.5ARI 24 at NYG 36
DAL at HOU
Sun 1:00 PM
HOU −2.5HOU −3+0.5
★☆☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −6.5DAL 34 at HOU 30
GB at TB
Sun 1:00 PM
TB +3.5TB −2.2+5.7
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +0.5GB 17 at TB 14
JAX at CIN
Sun 1:00 PM
JAX +2.5JAX +0.7+1.8
★★☆☆☆no play
Right · +7.5JAX 22 at CIN 17
LAR at PHI
Sun 1:00 PM
PHI +2.5PHI −0.7+3.2
★★☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −1.5LAR 24 at PHI 20
NE at BUF
Sun 1:00 PM
NE +7NE +5+2.0
★★☆☆☆no play
Right · +10.0NE 29 at BUF 26
NYJ at CHI
Sun 1:00 PM
NYJ +3.5NYJ +7.4−3.9
★☆☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −7.5NYJ 12 at CHI 23
TEN at BAL
Sun 1:00 PM
TEN +11.5TEN +9.5+2.0
★★☆☆☆no play
Right · +5.5TEN 18 at BAL 24
MIA at MIN
Sun 4:05 PM
MIA +10.5MIA +9.2+1.3
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +5.5MIA 10 at MIN 15
DEN at SF
Sun 4:25 PM
SF −3SF −3.1+0.1
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +7.0DEN 14 at SF 24
KC at LV
Sun 4:25 PM
KC −4.5KC −6.4+1.9
★★☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −1.5KC 30 at LV 27
LAC at SEA
Sun 4:25 PM
LAC +7LAC +4.3+2.7
★★☆☆☆no play
PushLAC 23 at SEA 30
DET at CAR
Sun 8:20 PM
CAR +3.5CAR +2.3+1.2
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +9.5DET 26 at CAR 32
ATL at NO
Mon 8:15 PM
ATL +3ATL +3.8−0.8
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +24.0ATL 45 at NO 24
Week 33–0–016 games · 3 picks · 13 leans · all graded

Sixteen games this week, three clear it. The top of the board is Detroit -6.5, where the market is pricing in 3.2 points of NYJ sentiment that ten days of rest doesn't support. Chicago +4.5 and Washington +7 both lean the same way, on numbers and public overreaction, even with the quarterback signal arguing the other direction in both spots. The live record is 0-0-0, which is another way of saying nothing has happened yet. Take the three, ignore the thirteen leans dressed up as opinions, and check back when there's an actual record to defend.

From the Sharp Model, off the week’s picks and the record so far.

Re-issued on 2026-09-23 under the market-anchored number, before any week 3 kickoff.

NYJ at DET

Sun, Sep 27, 1:00 PM ETGame page★★★☆☆

DET −6.5

Right · +0.5

Closed DET −6.5 · closed where we took it

Market DET −6.5 over NYJ. The market’s own numbers make this line 3.2 points too kind to NYJ. Results add 2.0 toward NYJ. Our number DET −7.7, an edge of +1.2 before the signals. Line now DET −7.

  • Ratings · DET +1.2· right
  • Rest · DET +1.5· right
  • The market's own numbers make this line 3.2 points too kind to NYJ; results move the number 2 toward NYJ, from DET giving 9.7 to NYJ to DET giving 7.7 to NYJ.
  • DET come in on 10 days' rest to NYJ's 7.

DET giving 6.5 to NYJ, and this desk takes DET. The gap says the market's own numbers make this line 3.2 points too kind to NYJ, and the form has already moved the number 2 points toward NYJ, from DET giving 9.7 down to 7.7 — our number still sits 1.2 points better than the posted line. Add DET coming in on 10 days' rest against NYJ's 7, and both signals point the same direction. DET's 0-2-0 against the spread record means nothing here; this is a live 3-star Sharp side, and the number, not the record, is why.

From the Sharp Model, off the numbers on this card and nothing else.

Final: NYJ 24 at DET 31

Line history7 pulls

DET: opened −6.5 · taken at −6.5 · closed −6.5

Closed where we took it

The median spread across the books at each pull we hold, on our side. The first pull is where our history starts, not the book’s own opener.

SEA at WAS

Sun, Sep 27, 1:00 PM ETGame page★★★☆☆

WAS +7

Right · +9.0

Closed WAS +8 · gave up 1.0 to the close

Market SEA −7 over WAS. The market’s own numbers make this line 7.5 points too kind to SEA. Results add 2.0 toward SEA. Our number WAS +1.5, an edge of +5.5 before the signals. Line now WAS +8.5.

  • Ratings · WAS +5.5· right
  • Public · WAS +1.0· right
  • Quarterback · SEA +4.0· wrong
  • The market's own numbers make this line 7.5 points too kind to SEA; results move the number 2 toward SEA, from WAS giving 0.5 to SEA to SEA giving 1.5 to WAS.
  • 94% of the spread money is on SEA. That is a point to WAS.
  • WAS's top quarterback, Jayden Daniels, is listed Out.

SEA giving 7 to WAS is the number, and it's wrong by 5.5 points according to the market's own numbers, which peg this closer to SEA giving 1.5. Add in that 94% of the spread money is piled on SEA, a point in WAS's favor by itself, and you've got two signals stacked the same direction. The counterweight is real: Jayden Daniels is out, worth 4 points to SEA, but it isn't enough to close a 5.5-point gap. Take WAS at 7, three stars, and don't let the quarterback news talk you out of math that already priced it in.

From the Sharp Model, off the numbers on this card and nothing else.

Final: SEA 31 at WAS 33

Line history7 pulls

WAS: opened +6.5 · taken at +7 · closed +8

Lost 1 to the close

The median spread across the books at each pull we hold, on our side. The first pull is where our history starts, not the book’s own opener.

PHI at CHI

Mon, Sep 28, 8:15 PM ETGame page★★★☆☆

CHI +4.5

Right · +24.5

Closed CHI +4 · beat the close by 0.5

Market PHI −4.5 over CHI. The market’s own numbers make this line 5.6 points too kind to PHI. Results add 0.9 toward CHI. Our number CHI −2, an edge of +6.5 before the signals. Line now CHI +3.5.

  • Ratings · CHI +6.5· right
  • Public · CHI +1.0· right
  • Quarterback · PHI +4.0· wrong
  • The market's own numbers make this line 5.6 points too kind to PHI; results move the number 0.9 toward CHI, from CHI giving 1.1 to PHI to CHI giving 2 to PHI.
  • 78% of the spread money is on PHI. That is a point to CHI.
  • CHI's top quarterback, Caleb Williams, is listed Doubtful.

PHI giving 4.5 to CHI, and the desk takes CHI. The market's own numbers make this line 5.6 points too kind to PHI, results move the number 0.9 toward CHI from CHI giving 1.1 to PHI to CHI giving 2 to PHI, and that puts our number 6.5 points off the actual line. Add in 78% of the spread money sitting on PHI, a point to CHI by itself, and the gap is doing real work even before you account for Williams listed Doubtful, which pulls 4 points back the other way and is the whole reason this sits at 3 stars instead of higher. Take CHI here; the quarterback signal is noted, not ignored, and it still isn't enough to close a 6.5-point hole.

From the Sharp Model, off the numbers on this card and nothing else.

Final: PHI 7 at CHI 27

Line history7 pulls

CHI: opened +3.5 · taken at +4.5 · closed +4

Beat the close by 0.5

The median spread across the books at each pull we hold, on our side. The first pull is where our history starts, not the book’s own opener.

GameSideOursEdgeStarsResult
ATL at GB
Thu 8:15 PM
GB −5.5GB −6.6+1.1
★☆☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −26.5ATL 35 at GB 14
CAR at CLE
Sun 1:00 PM
CLE +2.5CLE +2.9−0.4
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +5.5CAR 18 at CLE 21
CIN at PIT
Sun 1:00 PM
PIT +3.5PIT +3.50.0
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +6.5CIN 27 at PIT 30
HOU at IND
Sun 1:00 PM
IND +3IND +2+1.0
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +5.0HOU 17 at IND 19
KC at MIA
Sun 1:00 PM
MIA +11.5MIA +11.1+0.4
★☆☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −2.5KC 24 at MIA 10
LAC at BUF
Sun 1:00 PM
LAC +7LAC +5.9+1.1
★☆☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −1.0LAC 16 at BUF 24
NE at JAX
Sun 1:00 PM
NE +3NE −0.5+3.5
★★☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −26.0NE 6 at JAX 35
NYJ at DET
Sun 1:00 PM
DET −6.5DET −7.7+1.2
★★★☆☆
Right · +0.5NYJ 24 at DET 31
SEA at WAS
Sun 1:00 PM
WAS +7WAS +1.5+5.5
★★★☆☆
Right · +9.0SEA 31 at WAS 33
TEN at NYG
Sun 1:00 PM
TEN +2.5TEN +3−0.5
★★☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −2.5TEN 7 at NYG 12
ARI at SF
Sun 4:05 PM
ARI +8.5ARI +9.3−0.8
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +2.5ARI 30 at SF 36
MIN at TB
Sun 4:05 PM
TB +1.5TB −1.8+3.3
★★☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −5.5MIN 23 at TB 16
BAL at DAL
Sun 4:25 PM
DAL +3.5DAL +1.2+2.3
★★☆☆☆no play
Right · +0.5BAL 34 at DAL 31
LV at NO
Sun 4:25 PM
LV +3LV +1.3+1.7
★★☆☆☆no play
Right · +11.0LV 35 at NO 27
LAR at DEN
Sun 8:20 PM
DEN +2.5DEN +1.1+1.4
★★☆☆☆no play
Right · +6.5LAR 26 at DEN 30
PHI at CHI
Mon 8:15 PM
CHI +4.5CHI −2+6.5
★★★☆☆
Right · +24.5PHI 7 at CHI 27
Week 20–0–016 games · 0 picks · 16 leans · all gradedBacktest

Week 2 was run after the fact against the closing line. That makes it a demonstration of the system, not a record. Week 2 had too few lines on the season for the market's own numbers to hold an opinion, so every game was a lean: 16 games in the table and nothing to grade.

Sharp Model lead, numbers only.

GameSideOursEdgeStarsResult
DET at BUF
Thu 8:15 PM
DET +5.5DET +3.9+1.6
★★☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −4.5DET 31 at BUF 41
CAR at ATL
Sun 1:00 PM
ATL +2.5ATL +0.5+2.0
★★☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −28.5CAR 34 at ATL 3
CIN at HOU
Sun 1:00 PM
CIN +3CIN +1.3+1.7
★★☆☆☆no play
Right · +17.0CIN 20 at HOU 6
CLE at TB
Sun 1:00 PM
CLE +8.5CLE +7.1+1.4
★★☆☆☆no play
Right · +12.5CLE 23 at TB 19
GB at NYJ
Sun 1:00 PM
NYJ +3.5NYJ +1.5+2.0
★★☆☆☆no play
Right · +0.5GB 20 at NYJ 17
MIN at CHI
Sun 1:00 PM
MIN +4.5MIN +3.5+1.0
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +10.5MIN 9 at CHI 3
NO at BAL
Sun 1:00 PM
NO +8.5NO +7.5+1.0
★★☆☆☆no play
Right · +15.5NO 24 at BAL 17
PHI at TEN
Sun 1:00 PM
TEN +7TEN +5.3+1.7
★★☆☆☆no play
Right · +3.0PHI 24 at TEN 20
PIT at NE
Sun 1:00 PM
NE −4.5NE −3.3−1.2
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +12.5PIT 3 at NE 20
JAX at DEN
Sun 4:05 PM
JAX +2.5JAX +0.5+2.0
★☆☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −4.5JAX 13 at DEN 20
LV at LAC
Sun 4:05 PM
LV +6.5LV +4.5+2.0
★★☆☆☆no play
Right · +18.5LV 26 at LAC 14
MIA at SF
Sun 4:25 PM
SF −12.5SF −11.7−0.8
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +9.5MIA 13 at SF 35
SEA at ARI
Sun 4:25 PM
SEA −3.5SEA −3.1−0.4
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +20.5SEA 31 at ARI 7
WAS at DAL
Sun 4:25 PM
DAL −3.5DAL −2.7−0.8
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +13.5WAS 20 at DAL 37
IND at KC
Sun 8:20 PM
KC −6KC −7.2+1.2
★☆☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −3.0IND 30 at KC 33
NYG at LAR
Mon 8:15 PM
NYG +6.5NYG +4.5+2.0
★☆☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −15.5NYG 6 at LAR 28

Close and CLV are blank on a backtest week: the line at pick already was the close, so there was nothing to beat.

Week 10–0–016 games · 0 picks · 16 leans · all gradedBacktest

Week 1 was run after the fact against the closing line. That makes it a demonstration of the system, not a record. Week 1 had too few lines on the season for the market's own numbers to hold an opinion, so every game was a lean: 16 games in the table and nothing to grade.

Sharp Model lead, numbers only.

GameSideOursEdgeStarsResult
NE at SEA
Wed 8:20 PM
NE +3NE +2.2+0.8
★☆☆☆☆no play
PushNE 10 at SEA 13
SF at LAR
Thu 8:35 PM
SF +3.5SF +3.4+0.1
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +23.5SF 27 at LAR 7
ATL at PIT
Sun 1:00 PM
ATL +6.5ATL +4.5+2.0
★★☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −0.5ATL 13 at PIT 20
BAL at IND
Sun 1:00 PM
IND +3IND +2.4+0.6
★☆☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −15.0BAL 41 at IND 23
BUF at HOU
Sun 1:00 PM
HOU +1.5HOU +0.4+1.1
★☆☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −3.5BUF 36 at HOU 31
CHI at CAR
Sun 1:00 PM
CAR +3CAR +1.6+1.4
★☆☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −19.0CHI 59 at CAR 37
CLE at JAX
Sun 1:00 PM
CLE +8.5CLE +6.5+2.0
★★☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −15.5CLE 10 at JAX 34
NO at DET
Sun 1:00 PM
NO +7NO +5.5+1.5
★★☆☆☆no play
Right · +6.0NO 30 at DET 31
NYJ at TEN
Sun 1:00 PM
TEN −1.5TEN −1.9+0.4
★☆☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −14.5NYJ 23 at TEN 10
TB at CIN
Sun 1:00 PM
TB +3.5TB +3.4+0.1
★☆☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −2.5TB 27 at CIN 33
ARI at LAC
Sun 4:25 PM
ARI +8.5ARI +7.5+1.0
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +20.5ARI 26 at LAC 14
GB at MIN
Sun 4:25 PM
GB +1.5GB +1.1+0.4
★☆☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −15.5GB 22 at MIN 39
MIA at LV
Sun 4:25 PM
LV −3LV −3.1+0.1
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +11.0MIA 13 at LV 27
WAS at PHI
Sun 4:25 PM
WAS +6WAS +5+1.0
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +4.0WAS 22 at PHI 24
DAL at NYG
Sun 8:20 PM
NYG +3NYG +1.6+1.4
★☆☆☆☆no play
Right · +11.0DAL 20 at NYG 28
DEN at KC
Mon 8:15 PM
DEN +2.5DEN +2.4+0.1
★☆☆☆☆no play
Wrong · −18.5DEN 10 at KC 31

Close and CLV are blank on a backtest week: the line at pick already was the close, so there was nothing to beat.

How it works

The number starts from the market’s own numbers. Every posted line of the season so far is fitted to a rating for each team and one figure for home field, and the game being priced is left out of its own fit, so the market number for a game is what the rest of the season’s lines say it should be, not the line itself. The fit needs at least 32 lines; under that the market number is the posted line, the system holds no opinion, and every game is a lean. The market gap is the market number against the line, and it is stated on every pick as its own fact: the market’s own numbers make this line so many points too kind to one side.

Results are then allowed to speak, within limits. A second rating is fitted to the margins actually played, every margin capped at 21 points, blended toward a preseason prior from win totals at 0.85 points a win, with results weighted at played over played plus 6 and home field of 1.5 points. The form is half of the gap between that number and the market number, capped at 2 points either way, so results can move the market number and never replace it. Our spread is the market number plus the form, and the edge is our spread against the line. The form is printed on every pick as a fact beside the market gap; it is never an edge on its own.

Four signals move the edge by fixed amounts, and each keeps its own record above. Rest: a gap of 3 days or more between the two teams’ rest is 1.5 points to the rested side. Public: when 65% or more of the spread money is on one side, 1 point goes the other way. Weather: an outdoor game with wind at 20 mph or more, or a 60% or higher chance of rain, is 1 point to the underdog on the market line, and nothing on a pick’em. Quarterback: a team whose starting quarterback is out is docked 4 points, on live weeks only, because an injury status is a fact about now and not about a week that has already been played.

The gate. A game is a pick only when three things hold: the market gap is 3 points or more; at least one of the four signals fired on the same side as the gap; and the lean, the edge plus the signals, lands on that same side. A gap and one agreeing signal outweighed by the signals against and the form is a lean, never a pick the other way: a pick’s case never argues against its own side. Otherwise it is a lean. Every game gets a side, whichever team the lean favours, with a number of exactly zero going to the home side. Stars are bands on the size of that number: under 1.5 is one star, under 3 is two, under 4.5 is three, under 6 is four, and anything more is five; a pick is never fewer than three and a lean never more than two. Three stars and up are the Sharp picks and get a written case. One and two stars are leans, not picks: the side the number tilts to without clearing the gate, so they sit in the week table marked no play and are counted nowhere, not in the headline, not by stars, not in the backtest.

Over thirteen seasons the market-gap rule alone ran 51% against the close, and break-even is 52%. The ratings claim no edge. The signals are the case, and the closing-line block is where they are proved or not.

A pick is frozen the first time it is published with a line before kickoff: the side, the stars, the signals, the case and the line it was made against never change after that. A later run can update the current line, the score and the grade, and nothing else. The one exception is stated on the week it applies to, under the lead. A game that reaches kickoff without a line gets no row. When a live pick grades, the closing line is recorded beside it: the median spread across books from the last pull before kickoff, and how far the market moved toward our side between the pick and the close. Beating the close is the measure that survives one week’s scores, and it is kept in its own block above. Weeks 1 and 2 were run after the fact against the closing line and are labelled a backtest: a demonstration of the system, not a record.

The market ratings are the one thing fitted here, and they are fitted to the market’s lines, not to our results. Every other constant is stated so it can be argued with, and stays where it is until there are enough weeks to fit it honestly. The case on a pick and the lead on a week come from the Sharp Model, off the numbers on this page and nothing else; when the written case does not land, a numbers-only case stands in and says so. This page is a record of a system, kept in public. It is not a recommendation to do anything with it.

Week 11 ratings32 teams, best first. Points better than the average team. The market fit puts home field at 1.5.
TeamMarketResultsPriorMarginsWeight
BUF+5.4+6.0+1.7+6.00.60
JAX+4.6+6.00.0+6.00.60
SEA+4.4+3.1+1.7+3.10.63
KC+4.4+4.7+1.7+4.70.60
LAR+4.2+3.3+2.5+3.30.63
CIN+3.7+5.9+1.7+5.90.60
HOU+3.7+1.0+0.8+1.00.60
DEN+3.5+2.0+0.8+2.00.60
SF+3.4+5.3+0.8+5.30.60
DET+2.7+3.5+1.7+3.50.60
CHI+2.0+4.2+0.8+4.20.60
NE+1.7+0.3+1.7+0.30.63
DAL+1.3−0.1+0.8−0.10.63
MIN+1.1+3.60.0+3.60.60
BAL+0.9−2.0+2.5−2.00.63
GB+0.8+1.0+0.8+1.00.63
PIT+0.6+1.00.0+1.00.60
CAR−0.5−1.5−0.8−1.50.60
LAC−0.8−5.3+0.8−5.30.60
ATL−1.7−2.0−0.8−2.00.63
TB−1.9+1.60.0+1.60.60
PHI−2.4−4.1+1.7−4.10.60
IND−2.4−3.3−0.8−3.30.63
NO−2.9−2.8−0.8−2.80.60
LV−3.2−2.6−2.5−2.60.63
WAS−3.4−2.2−0.8−2.20.60
NYJ−3.6−4.4−2.5−4.40.63
NYG−3.9−1.0−0.8−1.00.60
CLE−4.1−3.2−2.5−3.20.63
ARI−4.5−6.3−4.3−6.30.63
MIA−6.4−5.9−4.3−5.90.60
TEN−6.9−5.7−1.7−5.70.60